I would love to help you with some color selections.
Thank you for posting your coloring and foundation shades currently. That does help.
If you are similar in coloring to Sara you have a lot of choices. The Lindsay palette would be a great natural look for you that you could easily take to night using the deeper shades for definition. You can even use the darkest shade Lilo wet as a liner.
The Scarlett palette has a bit more color. The blushes are a bit deeper, still a natural palette.
I would also recommend the Pretty palette and the Essentials palette. They are great introductions to the brand and are essentials to your everyday make up.
I hope this helps.
-Tricia